So they just fail from the additional weight?
Interesting...
Here is an e-mail I had with John Craig from Limit Engineering some time ago:
Mike,
I don't know which compressor wheel your turbocharger builder used. I looked at some
TB03 (same as T28) compressor figures and I still don't think you have a problem as long
as your turbocharger builder did things properly. At 24 PSI (2.63 pressure ratio) I estimate
that your turbocharger is turning about 150,000 RPM. If the turbocharger is balanced
properly, RPM is not the problem. As boost levels rise, thrust increases. Stock thrust
bearings are easily over loaded. If your turbocharger builder didn't use the proper thrust
bearing, then you have a failure waiting to happen.
It makes sense to me, that your boost increased after changing exhaust pipes. That turbo
was designed to run with a specific amount of backpressure. By changing exhaust pipes,
you removed that backpressure.
What do you mean by "clipped vanes"?
Regards,
John
To:
johncraig@limitengineering.com
Sent: Wednesday, December 31, 2003 12:12 AM
Subject: Dodge VNT Turbo
John,
I spoke to you a few weeks ago about a few technical questions on VNT25 Turbo for my 1990 Dodge Shadow VNT. This is what my setup is currently running:
-Ported intake manifold
-ported exhaust manifold
-52 mm Throttle body
-VNT25 Turbo (modified to VNT28...larger compressor wheel, clipped vanes)
-full 3 inch exhaust
-Adj. fuel pressure reg.
-Ported head w/+1 mm valves
-cone filter
Since I dropped in the 3 inch exhaust, the boost jumped from 16 psi to about 20-24 psi. I was told by the company that built the turbo that going over 18 psi with the turbo would basically make the turbo overspin and destoy the shaft. I did a little research and called a few other Turbo shops and they pretty much told me that the shaft speeds at that boost level would be well over 180k rpm, and that it would lead for definate turbo failure. You were the only person to tell me that the turbo would not grenade, and that I could run the boost right up to 30 psi without any problems as long as it had a good supply of oil (I run Mobil 15w50 synthetic) and a good supply of coolant.
In talking back to other Dodge VNT Turbo owners on Turbododge.com, I was pretty much told same thing and that I should look to finding a way to get my SBEC reprogrammed, or find a way to limit the boost. Are there any technical reports or any type of documentation I can find to disprove all the naysayers, or can you tell me of anything I should or should not do with this engine setup? I have to say this car runs great and is a blast to drive, but I am concerned on the turbo not lasting....
Thanks for your help or any guidance you can supply.
Mike
Now I am not certainly knocking any imput from a turbo builder, but for a long time now, I have yet to hear anyone agree on the VNT turbo and acceptable boost levels. I just talked to TEC the other day about the S60 (or S62 if you will) and asked them the same questions and I was given CFM for the upgraded turbos and the overall boost they would run would be 25 psi on a VNT28 and over that on a S60 or S62. I asked about shaft speeds, etc. and I got the same response as I did from Jon Craig some years ago (good oil and proper balancing, etc.) I was told the Super60 (or 62) would push in the 260hp range but was not told of a boost level/pressure. I know Neil E. was heavily into the VNT stuff, maybe he and Will can add some here.